After the Fall of the Hammer:
Frankenstein films from the early 1970s to the 1990s (3)
Terror of Frankenstein
(1976)
A widely ignored entry in the Frankenstein filmography, this
Irish-Swedish production directed by Calvin Floyd, is probably the one
adaptation of Shelley’s novel that can honestly claim to be faithful to
the original. From its beginning in an Arctic setting, it manages to
incorporate the narrative framework, where Frankenstein recounts his
story to Robert Walton, and then further on quite closely follows the
course of the novel.
Not quite the most impressing Frankenstein: Leon Vitali
|
Due to its limited duration of 90 minutes,
naturally the filmmakers had
to cut out several subplots, most prominently the framing of Justine for
William’s murder. In general, the narrative progresses quite quickly,
often leaving those viewers unfamiliar with the novel longing for
more explanation or simply more time to work things out.
Quite atypically for a 1970s horror movie, Terror of Frankenstein
focuses on the characters’ psychological development rather than on
action and bloodshed. There are no gory images, no gratuitous nudity,
and no horse-coach chases. Even the re-animation sequence is extremely
low-key: Leon Vitali’s Victor Frankenstein has no fancy laboratory
equipment, no gigantic machinery, just a kite attached to a wire during
a thunderstorm. |
The Monster is also far from previous incarnations such as Karloff's or
Christopher Lee's. Per Oscarsson actually looks like a re-animated
corpse, and his whole appearance is rather that of an evil, psychotic
mass murderer, than that of a freak made up from body parts. Of course
this fits perfectly with his character, the rejected, angst-filled, yet
violent creature. He speaks like a literate man (although with a
horrible Swedish accent) and his actions are the direct consequences of
how he is treated by his creator and society. |
Per Oscarsson as the Monster that is
able to read
...with a Swedish accent |
The film’s strongest assets are surely the beautiful period costumes and
realistic settings, combined with an eerie atmosphere and a mostly cold,
snowy landscape. This time Victor Frankenstein and his creature are
definitely alone, a fact that is emphasized by the sparse use of extras
and background characters (probably due to budget limitations).
The film's best bit: Stacy Dorning as Elizabeth |
On the contrary, the movie lacks tension and frightening horror elements.
Thanks to the slow pace, theatrical dialogue and a complete absence of
climactic story telling, the film mostly appears dull and boring. This
might prove that Mary Shelley’s novel simply does not translate well to
the screen, when it is not adapted to certain cinematic requirements. It
also shows that Shelley’s novel can be an excellent starting point to
come up with various new interpretations and adaptations, as it is
usually handled by filmmakers. However, this versions completely fails
to create an entertaining adaptation, mostly because it just translates
the novel
page by page
into a screenplay. |
Cast & Crew: |
|
|
|
Victor
Frankenstein |
Leon
Vitali |
Henry Clerval |
Nicholas Clay |
Monster |
Per Oscarsson |
Elizabeth |
Stacy Dorning |
|
|
|
|
Screenplay |
Calvin and
Yvonne Floyd |
Producer |
Calvin Floyd |
Director |
Calvin Floyd |
Frankenstein
(1984)
Another such minor Frankenstein film is a 1984 British made-for-television version,
directed by James Ormerod. Obviously filmed on an extremely low budget on videotape rather than film stock, the movie’s only strength is its first rate cast, including
Carrie Fisher of
Star Wars fame as Elizabeth, David Warner as the creature, John Gielgud as DeLacey
and Robert Powell as Victor Frankenstein. Relying mostly on dialogue, the movie appears very stagey and unspectacular in its cinematography. Despite the budgetary restrictions costumes and settings are rather convincing, but surely not enough to make for exciting entertainment.
|
Victor Frankenstein, king of hair (Robert Powell) |
Princess Leia or Elizabeth (Carrie Fisher)? |
At a length of approximately 90 minutes, Frankenstein basically follows the original novel,
including its depiction of the creature as a pitiful victim rather
than blood-thirsty monster. However, the movie heavily condenses the story and diverts from its literary source in several occasions:
In the movie Clerval assists Frankenstein in making his creature, which is also done at his castle rather than in Ingolstadt.
Awakened by Frankenstein, the creature flees and is taken in by an old, blind man named DeLacey,
who decides to teach the monster how to speak and read. This scene
clearly draws its influences from a similar scene in James Whale’s
Bride of Frankenstein,
even copying whole parts of its dialogue. Later the old man is murdered by
two villagers, who are then killed in revenge by the monster. |
There is also a
change in the circumstances of Justine’s death: Whereas in the novel the
creature frames her for William’s murder and she is sentenced to death,
in this movie version the frightened Justine runs away from the monster and plunges to
death from a mountain cliff. Screenwriter Victor Gialanella also abridges the whole ending of the story, probably also due to budgetary and run-time reasons, which made it impossible to include the Arctic setting of the original ending : When Victor refuses to create a mate for the creature using Justine’s body, the monsters sneaks to the lab and strangles Elizabeth. Victor discovers his dead bride and finally
realizes his fatal mistake: The only solution is to kill the monster. He proclaims to the monster, “You, who have no soul, will rest in peace. I am damned forever!” and destroys the laboratory burning both the monster and himself.
Burnt face victim or Frankenstein's creature? (David Warner) |
This film is surely only for Frankenstein completists or scholars,
but even they will have to admit that it is so terribly
unspectacular and boring that it is no wonder the film is
unavailable on DVD. The only chance to catch a glimpse of it is on
youtube, where a rather worn-out VHS-copy can be watched split into eight
parts.
|
Cast & Crew: |
|
|
|
Victor
Frankenstein |
Robert Powell |
Henry
Clerval |
Terence Alexander |
Monster |
David Warner |
Elizabeth |
Carrie Fisher |
DeLacey |
John Gielgud |
|
|
Screenplay |
Victor Gialanella |
Director |
James Ormerod |
© 1999-2010 Andreas Rohrmoser
|